Planning a Project
Planning a MAP: What MAP Students and Mentors Need to Know
Criteria for a MAP Detailed instructions for students on developing a successful MAP application The Top 10 Ways to Persuade an Institutional Review Board to Reject Your Research Proposal David Lopatto, Ann Ellis CUR Focus, Spring 2010, Vol 30, No 3
As you plan a Mentored Advanced Project, you should begin by thinking about the scope and desired results of your culminating scholarly or creative project. MAP applications must include a specific off-campus venue in order to be considered. Students will not be held to this venue, but need to have a goal in mind.
The interested student and potential faculty mentor should discuss:
- different possibilities for the project;the student's educational goals;the student's course history as preparation for the MAP;how the project fits into the student's four-year academic plan;how the project can connect with the faculty member's areas of interest in scholarship and/or teaching;
The student and faculty mentor need to consider:
- the methodology and timetable for the project;how often they would meet;the type of final product resulting from the MAP (in the case of a two-semester MAP, the student must provide the mentor with gradable work in both semesters);and what resources would be needed to carry out this project.
MAP Credits The Mentored Advanced Project takes place under the direct and continuous supervision of a Grinnell faculty member. The project must comprise a total of 4, 6, or 8 credits, with no more than 4 credits earned in a single semester or summer. Although a MAP component may earn 2 credits (for example, you might follow-up a four credit summer MAP with a two-credit MAP in the fall where you finish up the research and write the final draft of a research paper) there are no 2-credit MAPs. Background or preparatory work is best pursued as a regular Independent Study in advance of the MAP. The MAP proposal, including a description of all components of the project, should be submitted at the time of registering for the first component. Multi-term MAPs should begin with a 4-credit component. Please see the summary of theCurriculum Committee's Resolutions for more details.
Applying for a MAP To propose a MAP, use the application form available from the Registrar and also online. Applications for summer MAPs and academic year MAPs can be found athttp://www.grinnell.edu/offices/registrar/additionalinfo/forms/ Summer MAP students in the Humanities and Social Studies divisions must also include aSummer MAP Student Information form.
Faculty MAP Report and Compensation Faculty must file a report at the conclusion of the MAP. An on-line version of the report can be found at MAP Report Form. Compensation will be forfeit if the report is not completed within four months of completing the MAP. Multi-term MAPs require a report for each semester. There are three typical modes of compensation for accumulated MAPs: See Compensation
Clarification of Roles - Co-directorship versus 2nd reader: When a MAP isco-directed, it is assumed that both advisors share equal responsibility in mentoring the student. In a co-directed MAP, both directors guide the development, design, execution and evaluation of the product, each submit individual reports and both faculty members split the MAP credit. A second reader evaluates a draft of the product and gives feedback to the student and mentor. The second reader receives a $300 stipend for his/her evaluation. This compensation will be administered once the primary director states in the final MAP report that the second reader has fulfilled his/her responsibilities.
Dates to remember:
Faculty Date Due Application for Summer MAP funding from CSFS 1st Friday in February Summer MAPs also require the submission of a student MAP application and Summer MAP Student Information Form See Registrar Dates to Remember for application deadline. Information form due early April 299/499 Report Form On completion of 299 or 499 (two reports needed for 2-part projects) Student Date Due Student MAP application Registrar Dates to Remember Note: Summer MAPs also require the submission of a faculty request for funding (above). Academic Year MAP applications 1st Monday following end of Preregistration Students on OCS the semester prior to the MAP, or who are applying for the second semester of a 2-part MAP 1st Friday of first full week of classes Completed MAP applications should be returned to the Registrar's Office.
Planning a Project During the Year
Planning a MAP during the Academic Year
Application The MAP application form is available from the Registrar's Office, including an online printable form athttp://www.grinnell.edu/offices/registrar/additionalinfo/forms/. The deadline for proposing a MAP or any other Independent Study during the academic year falls on Monday of the week following the end of the pre-registration period. Deadline for students who were on Off-Campus Study the semester prior to the MAP, or who are applying for the second semester of a two-part MAP is the Friday of the first full week of classes.
The application should set out a clear set of goals and a highly detailed plan, including the questions or problems you intend to address and how you intend to go about addressing them.
Supplies needed to complete the project (poster, artwork, photocopies, etc.) are the responsibility of the student and the academic department. If your MAP will incur special costs or expenses, please be sure to include a tentative budget with the application.
Planning a Project During the Summer
Planning a Summer MAP
Timing and Time Commitment The standard ten-week period for a summer MAP begins with the week of Memorial Day and ends in early August. Summer MAPs require both a faculty request for funding (due 1st Friday in February) and a student MAP application. For information on deadlines, please click on The Dates to Remember Drawer lower down on this page. Planning summer MAPs must begin very early. All summer MAP students receive a stipend awarded by the Committee for the Support of Faculty Scholarship, so faculty desirous of mentoring students in an advanced project during the summer must submit a grant request form by the third Friday in February. A CSFS grant request for funding is necessary for student-initiated projects as well as for MAPs based on a faculty member's research. Summer MAPs differ from those pursued during the academic year. The summer MAP is expected to be a full-time on-campus endeavor (this is why the College pays a stipend to the summer MAP student, as well as why students cannot be employed elsewhere on campus during the MAP). Mentors are expected to provide frequent and regular supervision, including at least two regularly scheduled meeting per week that the MAP is conducted.
Defining Projects and Identifying Summer MAP Students and MentorsFaculty members who normally use student assistants in their summer research programs apply for funds for student summer stipends as a matter of course each year, and identify qualified MAP candidates late in the Spring semester. Because summers are reserved for faculty research, opportunities for student-initiated summer MAP projects are very restricted. Students who hope to pursue a summer research program of their own devising must discuss their plans with potential mentors well before the February deadline for summer grant requests. They should develop for the application a clear set of goals and a highly detailed plan, including the questions or problems they intend to address and how they intend to go about addressing them. Students who are on a Personal leave of Absence or an Emergency/Medical Leave of Absence are eligible for summer independent study, directed research or MAPS, provided the following conditions are in place:
- The MAP meets Grinnell’s standards for summer MAPS
- The student has filed a personal or emergency/medical leave return letter and has been granted approval to return for the subsequent semester
- The student will be registering in April for fall classes
- The student must sign a promissory note agreeing to repay the stipend and appropriate tuition for the credits they earned if they do not enroll for the fall term.
Funding To secure funding for a summer MAP, the faculty member needs to submit a request to the Committee on Support of Faculty Scholarship (CSFS) in early February. The form is available online athttps://itwebforms.grinnell.edu/apps/dean/grantrequest/. This request normally includes a stipend to support the MAP student during the summer, and in some cases modest expenses (such as research supplies (not including books)) needed to carry out the project.
The MAP application form is available from the Registrar's Office, including an online printable form athttp://www.grinnell.edu/offices/registrar/additionalinfo/forms/. For summer MAPs, the Registrar's deadline is too late to secure funding for a project if your faculty mentor did not do so by the February deadline. There are two parts to summer MAP applications and two deadline options. Part A of the application, due in late April or early May, asks for the title and the plans for meetings and coursework. Students in the Humanities and Social Students must include a Summer MAP Student Information (found under the "Map Forms" drawer lower down on the page") Form with Part A. Part B asks the applicant to describe the project in detail. The MAP Director will determine whether Part B will be submitted in May or if the project will be better served by delaying Part B submission until June. The June deadline best suits MAPs where students are working on the faculty member's research. The May deadline better serves student-initiated projects by helping the student and director develop a clear set of expectations early on. It is important to remember that the application is not complete (and thus cannot be approved by the Dean's office) until both parts are submitted.
MAP students are eligible to rent college-owned housing, subject to availability, either for that ten-week period, or for a six-week period during the first half or second half of the summer. Initial deposits and rent can automatically be deducted from MAP stipend payments. To accommodate building maintenance needs, the earliest date for students to move into the college-owned housing will be Memorial Day, and it will not be possible to remain any later than the first full week of August. (link to summer housing) Students interested in learning more about this opportunity should contact the Residence Life Housing Office.
If the MAP student has not previously been employed by the college, the student needs to complete employment forms at the Cashier's Office. The student will need either a passport or a driver's license and social security card. It is not possible to receive a paycheck without filing these employment forms. Student paychecks are issued throughout the summer on alternate Fridays as determined by the Office of the Treasurer, and are available for pick-up at the Cashier's Office.
Dates to remember
Faculty Date Due Application for Summer MAP funding from CSFS 1st Friday in February Summer MAPs also require the submission of a student MAP application and Summer MAP Student Information Form (found in the "Map Forms" drawer lower down on this page) See Registrar Dates to Remember for application deadline. Information form due early April 299/499 Report Form On completion of 299 or 499 (two reports needed for 2-part projects) Student Date Due Student MAP application Registrar Dates to Remember Note: Summer MAPs also require the submission of a faculty request for funding (above). Academic Year MAP applications 1st Monday following end of Preregistration Students on OCS the semester prior to the MAP, or who are applying for the second semester of a 2-part MAP 1st Friday of first full week of classes Completed MAP applications should be returned to the Registrar's Office.
Student MAP Proposal Guidelines
Detailed instructions on developing a successful MAP application
In consultation with your faculty mentor, prepare a detailed formal proposal describing the topic and project that seeks to persuade your reader that your project is worth supporting. Of course, no scholar can ever predict the exact outcome of scholarly and creative work, so your final project may not match your proposal exactly; however, writing a strong proposal increases the likelihood that you will produce a successful product. Due to the inherent “advanced” nature of the MAP, make sure that the proposal shows how you are grappling at a deep level with what’s been done before in the discipline and how your project responds to that previous work. Your MAP application should demonstrate your ability to conduct such an advanced study. Overall, this proposal should argue, using evidence, that this project is important, academically rigorous, and likely to result in a product that makes a new contribution to the field of study.
Specific points to consider in preparing your application:
- A Mentored Advanced Project is an approved course of faculty-directed scholarly or creative work that culminates significant preparatory work. It integrates the knowledge and skills gained by your course of studies, and aims to produce results that merit dissemination to the wider scholarly community. Using this definition, argue that your proposed project is both advanced and integrative given the background and skills you bring to it.
- State your problem or hypothesis and clearly place it within the field of previous and ongoing work of others. This description should reflect a thorough review of the literature on your topic, to make sure you know what other scholars are doing and what conclusions they are coming to.
- Formulate and describe your approach to the project—the steps you will take to answer the questions/address the hypothesis you have already presented. Clearly and thoroughly articulate your methodology and why you will use this particular approach for your analysis, formation of a creative product, and/or data collection. Include references to particular influences and previous work that informs this process.
- Identify what your research will contribute to the body of knowledge in the disciplinary area in which you are working. What will those who review your final product learn about the larger field of scholarship within which your project falls?
- Pay attention to the requirements of academic honesty:
- Remember that this proposal is a scholarly piece of writing; as such it should represent your most careful formal writing. As with any scholarly piece of writing, you must attribute ideas and words to their sources clearly and consistently, using whatever citation system is accepted in your discipline.
- If you are proposing work that will be done in collaboration with others, whether faculty members or students, clarify what language and ideas belong to others and what are yours. Even if the project as a whole is collaborative, you must argue individually in your own words why the project represents advanced and integrative work for you.
Summary of Student Travel Guidelines
MAP STUDENT TRAVEL GUIDELINES
General Travel Expense Guidelines
Please complete a Travel Expense Voucher (under the "Travel Reimbursement Information" drawer) and return with original itemized receipts to the Dean's Office (Nollen 2nd) within thirty days from date of travel. If you need assistance, please contact Marcia Baker in the Dean's Office at ext. 3100.
Funds should not be committed for non-refundable expenses until receiving notification of approval.
Original itemized receipts are needed for all allowable expenses including transportation (except mileage), registration, and lodging. Receipts must be itemized and show specific items purchased.
- Normally, the rate available for student housing per night is $60. In some cases, the maximum expense available per student may be increased to $120 per night.
- The maximum total amount available for transportation is $300 for travel within 350 miles and $400 for distances greater than 350 miles. In some cases worked out with the Associate Dean's office, special funding may be available for subsidizing international travel. It is expected that travel dates and times will be selected to keep travel and lodging expenses low. Please make flight arrangements as early as possible to ensure the lowest possible fares. Those driving will be reimbursed at $0.555 per mile, plus parking and tolls. Expenses for ground transportation to and from the Des Airport may be reimbursed up to $66. Expenses for ground transportation to and from the Cedar Rapids airport may be reimbursed up to $88.
Students traveling to conduct research during the MAP
Budgets for Summer MAPs are submitted by faculty MAP directors in February. Budgets for Fall and Spring MAPs should be included within the student's MAP application.
Since Summer MAP students already receive stipends intended to cover their living expenses, summer MAP students may only be partially reimbursed for lodging and transportation expenses in significant excess of those expenses for living in Grinnell.
Students traveling to give a presentation at a professional conference
Students are eligible to receive funding for presentation of their MAP results up to a year after completion of the MAP. All applications should be submitted three months before the beginning date of the conference. Notifications of funding will normally be made two months before the beginning date of the conference. Administration of funds is contingent on acceptance of the student's MAP results for presentation.
- Only "early registration" fees will be reimbursed. Membership fees and funds for extra conference activities will not be reimbursed.
- All students attending the same conference are expected to travel together and share lodging (up to four students per room). Lodging will only be reimbursed for stays occurring during the regular schedule of the conference.
- For conference days when meals are not included with registration, meals can be reimbursed up to $25 per day when original itemized receipts showing specific items purchased are provided. We recommend selecting a hotel that provides breakfast if possible. Keep in mind that we cannot reimburse for alcohol or non-food items.
Go to the: Student Travel Funding Request Form
Before the MAP:
- Academic Year Independent Study/MAP application (Fall or Spring Only)
- Checklist for Summer MAP Applications
- Summer MAP Funding Request (Faculty use)
- Summer MAP (499) Application (Student use)
- Summer MAP Student Information
After the MAP:
Compensation for Accumulated Mentored Advanced Projects (499) Credits
Compensation for Accumulated MAP (499) Credits
MAP teaching credits accumulate according to the following rubric as approved by the faculty in 2002."The faculty endorses the President's and Dean's recommendation that faculty shall accumulate teaching credit of 1/6 of a course for teaching a 4 or 6 credit MAP and ¼ course for an 8 credit MAP to be applied in accordance with a memorandum from the Dean's Office dated April 5th. It further endorses the President's and Dean's commitment to minimize any resulting departmental curricular disruptions. The faculty supports the principle that for part-time and temporary faculty compensation shall generally take the form of an appropriate stipend."
MAP Report Reports from the faculty supervisor of the MAP must be submitted in order to earn compensation. These reports are due one month after grades have been submitted. Compensation will be forfeit if reports have not been received within four (4) months of completing the MAP. Multi-term MAPs require a report for each semester.
Modes of Compensation There are three typical modes of compensation for accumulated MAPs:
- course releases , which may be taken during an academic year in consultation with a department
- extension of a scholarly leave to a full-time leave with payment on a pro rata basis
- cash stipends for term faculty or in some cases for continuing faculty
- Course Release
- When a faculty member accumulates a total of a course she or he may opt to teach one fewer course in an academic year. It is important for the faculty member and department to plan carefully for this so that the curriculum of the department is not seriously affected. The faculty member and department should discuss the plan with the Dean, usually in the fall semester before the academic year of the proposed course release.
- Scholarly Leave
- A faculty member may incorporate MAP credits as a part of a scholarly leave. If a faculty member is approved for a sabbatical leave and wishes to extend that leave for a full year, the MAP teaching credit can contribute to the half of salary not provided by the leave. MAP salary compensation is based upon a three course sabbatical leave which leaves two remaining courses in an annual teaching assignment. The salary for the year-long leave will be 50% salary plus 50% * (# MAP course credits/ 2courses). For example, if a faculty member has completed 6 MAP credits (compensated as 1 course credit), a full-year leave would be compensated at 50% + 25% of the faculty member's ordinary salary. Or, if a faculty member has completed 8 MAPs (compensated as 1.33 course credits), a full-year leave would be compensated at 50% + 33 % of her or his salary. Requests for such credit toward leave pay should be submitted at the time of the leave proposal. Only credits completed by the end of the spring semester (not including the subsequent summer) preceding the leave will be included in the leave compensation.
- Cash Compensation
- In the case of a term faculty member (who cannot accrue enough MAP credits to equal a full course) we will pay the individual according to the Compensation Schedule below. In some cases where a regular, continuing faculty member cannot take a course release in compensation for a MAP, we will apply the cash compensation in lieu of course credit.
- Compensation Schedule:
- 4-credit Co-directed - $500
- 4- or 6-credits - $1000
- 8-credits - $1500 total
Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow A department may apply for a Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow to help ameliorate the curricular effects of MAP compensation. The Mellon Fellow serves for two years and teaches two courses/year.
Clarification of Roles and Compensation:
Co-directorship versus 2nd reader:
When a MAP is co-directed, it is assumed that both advisors share equal responsibility in mentoring the student. In a co-directed MAP, both directors guide the development, design, execution and evaluation of the product, each submit individual reports and both faculty members split the MAP credit.
A second reader evaluates a draft of the product and gives feedback to the student and mentor. The second reader receives a $300 stipend for his/her evaluation. This compensation will be administered once the primary director states in the final MAP report that the second reader has fulfilled his/her responsibilities.