People Are Proud to be Americans but Tired of “Political Circus”

October 28, 2019

A strong majority of respondents (89%) to the newest edition of the Grinnell College National Poll say they are proud to be Americans, even while 87% say they are tired of the circus in politics. The poll, a partnership between Grinnell College and nationally renowned pollster J. Ann Selzer of Selzer & Company, was released Oct. 29, 2019.

“The exhaustion of the daily news cycle may be testing people’s limits,” said Ann Selzer, founder of Selzer & Company. “But it does not appear to dip into a fundamental sense of what this country is about.”

Percentage of participants asked if certain phrases described them answered from a high of 89 for proud to be an American to a low of 19 for socialist

Immigrant Influence is Positive on U.S. Culture and Economy

A majority of U.S. residents say immigrants mostly enrich (70%) rather than threaten (12%) American culture — and people who interact regularly with immigrants report more positive feelings. 81% of those who interact daily with immigrants say they enrich American culture. Those who report never interacting with immigrants in their daily life (15% of respondents) see things differently, with 48% saying immigrants mostly enrich and 30% saying they mostly pose a threat to American culture.

While 2016 Trump voters gave lower than average ratings on how immigrants enrich the culture, a majority, 54%, still find value in their cultural contributions.

Asked what effect immigrants have on American culture, 70 percent answered mostly enrich, 12 percent said mostly a threat, and 17 percent said not sure

“The first important insight from the poll is most Americans are not anti-immigrant,” said Eliza Willis, professor of political science at Grinnell College. “Although Republicans are somewhat less supportive than Democrats or independents, these positive attitudes prevail across party lines. Additionally, no matter what one’s party preference, more regular contact with immigrants is associated with more positive attitudes.”

Eliza Willis, Professor of Political Science

Immigrants’ influence on the U.S. economy is thought by more to be positive (61%) than negative (22%). Again, people who interact with immigrants report more positive feelings than those do who do not. Among those with daily interactions with immigrants, 73% say immigrants benefit the economy compared to 13% who do not. Those reporting possibly never interacting with immigrants have a different view — the ratio is 38%–44%.

Partisan differences over immigration emerge when asked about the effects of immigrants on the economy. Only 44% of Republicans and 39% of 2016 Trump voters feel immigrants positively affect the economy.

“The generally strong support for both immigrants and immigration to the U.S. helps to explain why the president’s approval rating on immigration is at only 40%,” said Associate Professor of Political Science at Grinnell College and Grinnell College National Poll Director Peter Hanson. “His anti-immigrant policies only resonate with a portion of the electorate.”  

Americans Open to Criminal Justice Reform

Logan Lee, Assistant Professor of Economics

After decades of tough-on-crimes policies that have boosted prison populations, Americans are open to reforms that would divert non-violent offenders from prison. 85% of Americans said they favor sending non-violent offenders to programs other than prison, such as drug courts, home arrest with GPS, etc., compared to 11% who opposed such a change. 58% favor stopping the practice of sending people on parole back to prison for minor, non-criminal parole violations, with 34% opposed.

Additionally, 76% of respondents are in favor of requiring judges to regularly review prisoners and release those who have been rehabilitated.

“This data points to optimism about changes in how we deal with non-violent offenders,” said Logan Lee, assistant professor of economics at Grinnell College. “Alternatives such as home arrest is something that’s way more feasible today than it’s ever been, and people recognize it as a legitimate option for non-violent offenders.”

Respondents were not as inclined to support lessening the sentences of first-time violent offenders with 38% in favor and 55% opposed.

Chart of percentage of particants responding in favor or opposed to the four incarcertion questions described in news article

The Grinnell College National Poll was conducted Oct. 17–23, 2019 for Grinnell College by Selzer & Co. of Des Moines, Iowa. It surveyed 1,003 U.S. adults ages 18 or older, with a margin of error of the full sample at +/- 3.1 percentage points. The respondents included 806 likely voters in the 2020 general election, with a margin of error among that group of +/- 3.5 percentage points. Detailed poll information, including toplines and methodology, can be found at Grinnell College National Poll.

We use cookies to enable essential services and functionality on our site, enhance your user experience, provide a better service through personalized content, collect data on how visitors interact with our site, and enable advertising services.

To accept the use of cookies and continue on to the site, click "I Agree." For more information about our use of cookies and to opt-out of cookies at any time, please refer to our website Privacy Policy.